Download Ought Implies Kant: A Reply to the Consequentialist Critique by Joel Marks PDF

By Joel Marks

Ought Implies Kant deals an unique safeguard of the moral conception of Immanuel Kant, and develops an extension of that theory's account of ethical accountability to incorporate direct tasks to nonhuman animals. The dialogue facilities on a severe exam of consequentialism, the view that the rightness or wrongness of an motion is set exclusively by way of its outcomes. Kantianism, in contrast, claims that the center of ethics is to regard all persons―or, in Joel Marks's view, all residing beings―as ends-in-themselves. The consequentialist criterion would appear to allow, certainly require, violating the respect of people (not to say the honor of alternative animals) if this may lead to a greater consequence. This quantity treats the consequentialist problem to Kantian ethics in numerous novel methods. first of all, the utilitarian model of consequentialism is delineated and defended through a conceptual machine dubbed by means of the writer because the Consequentialist Continuum. Marks then presents an exhaustive and definitive exposition of the really overlooked Epistemic Objection to utilitarianism. whereas acknowledging the intuitive charm of utilitarianism's center conviction―that we must always do what's for the best―Marks argues that this is often an very unlikely injunction to meet, or maybe to try to satisfy, simply because all the suitable result of our activities can by no means be recognized. Kantianism is then brought as a conceivable substitute account of our moral duties. Marks argues that Kantianism is definitely in the scope of ordinary human competence and conforms both good to our moral intuitions as soon as the theory's right interpretation is favored. despite the fact that, Kant's personal model has to be prolonged to house the rightful ethical attention we owe to nonhuman animals. ultimately, Marks employs the inspiration of a Consequentialist phantasm to provide an explanation for utilitarianism's carry on our ethical intuitions, whereas constructing a sort of Consequentialist Kantianism to deal with them.
An unique and penetrating exam of a imperative debate

Show description

Read or Download Ought Implies Kant: A Reply to the Consequentialist Critique PDF

Best philosophy criticism books

Maria Zambrano. Desde la sombra llameante (El Ojo del Tiempo) (Spanish Edition)

María Zambrano (1904-1991) se plantea desde sus primeros escritos l. a. relación entre filosofía y poesía, consolidando, junto al concepto de «razón vital», de Ortega y Gasset, el de «razón poética». A través de su aproximación a los angeles expresión lírica y los angeles mística, los angeles pensadora hace tomar cuerpo en el texto a las palabras de Wittgenstein: «la filosofía no es una doctrina, sino una actividad».

Know Thyself: An Essay on Social Personalism

Recognize Thyself: An Essay in Social Personalism proposes that social Personalism can top offer for self-knowledge. within the West, self-knowledge has been sought in the framework of 2 dominant highbrow traditions, order and the rising self. at the one hand, old and medieval philosophers dwelling in an orderly hierarchical society, ruled by means of honor and disgrace, and reinforced via the metaphysics of being and rationalism, believed individuals achieve self-knowledge via uniting with the floor in their being; as soon as united they might comprehend what they're, what they're to be, and what they're to do.

The Emergency of Being: On Heidegger’s “Contributions to Philosophy”

"The center of historical past, for Heidegger, isn't really a chain of occurrences however the eruption of value at severe junctures that deliver us into our personal via making all being, together with our being, into an pressing factor. In emergency, being emerges. "—from The Emergency of BeingThe esoteric Contributions to Philosophy, frequently thought of Martin Heidegger's moment major paintings after Being and Time, is essential to any interpretation of his concept.

The Evidence of Evolution: Uncovering the Faulty Science of Dawkins' Attack on Creationism

“There’s most likely No God. Now cease caring and revel in Your existence. ” This used to be the slogan plastered on billboards, buses, and benches throughout London to advertise the Out crusade spearheaded through professor Richard Dawkins. for many years, animal behaviorist and world-renowned atheist, professor Dawkins has attacked creationism and denounced the claims of the Bible.

Additional resources for Ought Implies Kant: A Reply to the Consequentialist Critique

Example text

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.62 of 5 – based on 29 votes